China: magnitude-7 earthquake strikes northern Tibet, killing at least 16 in the Nagqu region
the same fact, two accounts
this subject is more divergent than 52% of recent comparable stories
United StatesThe United States is measuring the catastrophe by the scale of relief efforts: the American press is detailing the race against the cold, altitude, and aftershocks around Nagqu, based on the tolls from the Xinhua agency.
What each one tells
opposition
SwitzerlandBern relays a report that comes almost exclusively from Chinese state media: the Swiss press reports the Tibet earthquake, specifying at each stage who provides the figures.
- United States
Logistical
the narrative highlights the material difficulties of the rescue efforts, above any political stakes.
Regional serialisation
the earthquake is linked to the recent floods on the Nepal-Tibet border.
What the account puts first
Switzerlandof territorial control
the narrative qualifies the region from the outset by its Chinese administrative status.
Relies on state media
the human and material toll is based on Chinese official agencies and channels, with no independent corroboration mentioned.
- United States
Reliance on Xinhua
the human toll is based on the Chinese state news agency, relayed via AFP.
What it leans on
United States onlySwitzerlandthis perspective does not carry this information
and the figures
Headlines side by side
What each country's press ran as a headline, as published, in its original language. These headlines are not translated.
United States
Headlines from the 22 other countries
Australia
Bangladesh
Belgium
Brazil
Canada
China
Italy
Colombia
Denmark
Finland
- Kiina | Tiibetissä voimakas maanjäristysHelsingin Sanomat
- Tiibetissä voimakas maanjäristysYLE Uutiset
- Maanjäristys Tiibetissä, ainakin toistakymmentä kuollutMTV Uutiset
France
Nepal
Peru
- Terremoto en China: imágenes del sismo de magnitud 7 en la región del Tíbet que deja 16 muertos y decenas de heridosRPP Noticias
- China: terremoto de magnitud 7 dejó al menos 16 muertos en la región del TíbetAndina
- Terremoto de magnitud 7 sacude el Tíbet chino y deja al menos 16 muertos y 32 heridosEl Comercio Perú
Philippines
Pakistan
Portugal
Romania
Serbia
Russia
Sweden
- Minst 16 döda efter jordskalv i Tibet | Senaste nytt på SvDSvenska Dagbladet
- Flera döda i Tibet efter jordskalvAftonbladet